Be Prepared (Graphic Novel)

Recommended Audience: Ages 14+

Opinion: Neutral with Advisories

Potential Benefits of Reading This: develop a sense of empathy, learn about a different culture (Russian Orthodox) and experiences (sleep away camp)

Advisories: bullying, trauma, hazing, crude language

Details: I feel that it is very important for readers to read about different cultures and backgrounds. It helps develop empathy, a broader worldview, and makes us better people in my humble opinion. For this reason, I took the dive and read Be Prepared by Russian American author Vera Brosgol. The story is based on an amalgamation of the author and her friend’s real experiences attending Russian youth camps in upstate New York. I feel that the biggest takeaway from reading this book is hopefully readers will develop a strong sense of empathy and pity for Vera and all that she experienced. The book is sad and Vera’s memories are frankly somewhat traumatic.

At camp, Vera experiences many struggles trying to fit in with the older girls at camp and witnesses many instances of bullying. As a reader, you can’t help but have your heart go out to her for all the awful things she is experiencing or witnessing. The book does not end with some great moral lesson or turn of events, in fact Vera doesn’t think she ever wants to go to camp again. In some ways, I appreciated that for what it was. At the end of the book, the author has a note for the readers explaining that she did not have positive experiences at camp and she really did struggle to make friends. I really appreciated her sharing that perspective because life really isn’t rosy all the time and that’s something to reflect upon.

That being said, there are definitely some factors that parents should consider when deciding whether or not they would want their child to read this. First of all, the experience of going to sleep away camp for weeks at a time may be something that Muslim parents don’t even want their children to read about as it is not something that they would want their children to experience for themselves. However, overall the experiences the author describes are not particularly pleasant so it might actually work in parents’ favor. There are several incidences of bullying, borderline hazing, that are described in the book, including a time where one of the character’s period-stained underwear are put on display on the flag post to humiliate her. Lastly, there are some depictions and promotion of Russian Orthodox religious beliefs and practices that some parents may not be comfortable with their child reading. I would definitely not recommend this book for elementary children at all. Perhaps a mature Middle School student may be able to read this with parental guidance.

In conclusion, would I let a high school student read this? Yes, I would, because I feel like there are some benefits there and hopefully a good discussion to follow. Would I necessarily recommend this book to others or put it in an Islamic school library? No, I would not.